The Frog Hollow Thanksgiving Pie Guide

The Frog Hollow Thanksgiving Pie Guide

Thanksgiving is a wonderful time for gathering around the table, sharing a delicious meal with people you love, and saving room for something sweet. And while there's plenty to do before the big day, dessert doesn't have to be another thing on your to-do list. This year, let Frog Hollow Farm help with the pie! 

Handmade in our farm kitchen, each of our pies brings something special to the table. From familiar holiday favorites with a twist to seasonal creations that make the most of our organic fruit, each one is made with care and a few special touches from Chef Becky. Here's a closer look at what's baking this Thanksgiving, along with everything you need to know to get your pie ready for the big day!

Meet Our Handmade Pies

Caramel Pumpkin Pie

A Thanksgiving classic with a little extra magic! Chef Becky gives traditional pumpkin pie a delicious twist with organic sugar pie pumpkins, roasted in our farm kitchen and blended with caramelized sugar for a silky, rich filling. A layer of gingersnap cookies tucked between the pumpkin custard and buttery, flaky crust adds just the right touch of spice and warmth.

How to serve: Remove from the freezer approximately 8 hours before serving and thaw completely in the refrigerator. Fully cooked and ready to enjoy!

Whiskey Pecan Pie

For those who like their holiday desserts a little decadent, this one's for you. Chef Becky's take on the iconic pecan pie features a classic pecan filling studded with our own organic dried fruit, soaked in whiskey. A thin layer of dark chocolate between the filling and flaky crust brings everything together for a dessert that's rich, memorable, and full of flavor.

How to serve: Remove from the freezer approximately 8 hours before serving and thaw completely in the refrigerator. No baking required!

Apple Pie

Sometimes, you just can't beat a classic. Our handmade Apple Pie is filled with organic sweet-tart apple slices and cozy spices, all tucked inside a golden, buttery double crust. It's the familiar taste of fall and the kind of dessert that feels right at home on every Thanksgiving table.

How to serve: Preheat the oven to 425°F with a sheet pan inside. Let the frozen pie thaw for 30 minutes, then place it on the preheated sheet pan and bake for 20 minutes.

Holiday Crostada

A celebration of the season's orchard bounty! This double-crust pastry brings together organic Warren pears, apples, currants, and our house-made candied organic orange peel. With its lovely combination of sweet fruit and bright citrus, it's especially delicious served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

How to serve: Preheat the oven to 400°F while the pastry rests on a baking sheet. Once the oven is at temperature, lightly brush the edges with egg wash, cream, milk, or water, then bake for 25–30 minutes until golden brown.

Pear Frangipane Galette

Looking for something a little unexpected? Our Pear Frangipane Galette makes a beautiful addition to the holiday table. Chef Becky poaches our hard-to-find organic Warren pears, known for their delicate sweetness, and pairs them with a soft, nutty almond filling. All of this is wrapped in our signature ruff-puff pastry for an elegant take on seasonal fruit dessert.

How to serve: Preheat the oven to 400°F and bake for 25–30 minutes, until the pastry edges are golden brown.

How to Order Your Thanksgiving Pie

We know there's already plenty happening in the kitchen on Thanksgiving, so we've made enjoying and ordering our pies as easy as possible. Each pie arrives frozen, with just a few simple steps between you and dessert! Here are a few ways to bring a Frog Hollow pie home for the holiday:

  1. Mail Order: Order online by Sunday, November 22, for delivery before Thanksgiving. Shop Frog Hollow Thanksgiving Pies

  2. Farmers Market Pickup: If you prefer to pick up your pie in person, we'll have pies available for pickup at our farmers markets on the following dates!:

  3. CSA Store: Order your pie through the Frog Hollow CSA Store for pickup with your CSA order. Thanksgiving week pickup days vary by location, so check your site’s holiday schedule.

Something Sweet to Be Thankful For

As Thanksgiving approaches, we're reminded how special it is to share good food with the people we love. From the fruit grown in our orchards to the handmade desserts prepared in our farm kitchen, we're so grateful for the bounty our farm provides and for the opportunity to bring a little Frog Hollow goodness to your holiday table.

Thank you for making us part of your celebrations and for supporting our farm. However you gather this Thanksgiving, we hope your table is full, your pie slices are generous, and that there's plenty to be thankful for!

 

Previous Article