Caramel Pumpkin Pie

Chef Becky puts a twist on the classic Pumpkin Pie to create a special dessert that will elevate any Thanksgiving! Made with organic sugar pie pumpkins that are roasted in our farm kitchen before being added to caramelized sugar, this Caramel Pumpkin Pie is silky smooth in texture and features the full flavors of fall. The pie crust is buttery and flaky, with a layer of gingersnap cookies nestled between the pumpkin custard and the dough to add an element of spiced warmth.


  • 9" pie serves 8-10


  • Velvety caramel pumpkin filling
  • A layer of Gingersnap cookie crumble
  • Tender, buttery crust
  • The perfect Thanksgiving dessert


Pie Dough: Organic flour, organic butter, pasture-raised leaf lard, water, organic sugar, salt.

Filling: Organic sugar, water, organic cream, organic pumpkin puree, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, salt, organic eggs.

All products are manufactured on equipment that processes Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, and Seeds. ** Known Allergen Ingredients

Storage & Handling

This pie is perishable and ships pre-baked and frozen with recommendations for serving.

Our Process

This isn’t your ordinary pumpkin pie! Chef Becky uses organic sugar pie pumpkins grown on the vine from our friends at Full Belly Farm to create this fall specialty. Each of these small, sweet pumpkins is roasted to perfection in our farm kitchen and then stirred into warm caramelized sugar. This delicious mixture is then poured into a pie crust that has been layered with a cozy gingersnap cookie crumble. The pie dough is made light and flaky from Chef Becky’s special mixture of organic butter and 100% pasture raised leaf lard from Prather Ranch. After baking, this Caramel Pumpkin pie is smooth, luscious, and silky - it feels almost like pumpkin flan rather than pie! This pie is truly a labor of love, which you can taste in each handcrafted bite. Slice this pie up for a memorable Thanksgiving dessert that you and your loved ones will want to make a new holiday tradition.

Customer Reviews

Based on 15 reviews
Saved out Thanksgiving

Needed help this Thanksgiving and this pie came through, plus the crust was perfection!

Sheri Jamieson

The caramel pumpkin pie was absolutely delicious. I would order again for the holidays!

Katherine Miller
Best pumpkin pie ever!

Best pumpkin pie we’ve ever had! It was absolute delicious!

Candy Serra

Caramel Pumpkin Pie

Karin Carlson
Best. Pie. Ever!

This is seriously the best pumpkin pie we have ever had. I hope this becomes a regular every holiday because I will never be able to find a pie that tastes this amazing! Perfect pie crust…yummy layer of buttery caramel and delicious pumpkin filling. So good!!

The Frog Hollow Farm Guarantee

Our promise to you: if your order doesn't arrive fresh and if you or your recipients aren't delighted, we'll make it right.

Carbon Neutral Shipping

Our commitment to the planet means that we offset the climate impact of every order with carbon-neutral shipping which supports projects that offset the emissions of the shipment's transport.

Always Fresh

To ensure freshness, orders placed after Tuesday at 11:59 PM will ship the following Monday, unless upgraded to Next Day Air or UPS Ground (1 Day).

Search our shop