Caramel Pumpkin Pie


No Thanksgiving is complete without a slice of Pumpkin Pie! And Chef Becky's version of this traditional dessert is made with Frog Hollow Farm-grown organic sugar pie pumpkins that are perfectly roasted in our farm kitchen before our artisan bakers add them to caramelized sugar to create a rich, over-the-top delicious pie.

A thin layer of gingersnap cookie crumbs is nestled between the custard and a light, flaky crust made using our chef's secret recipe.

Previously sold only at local California farmer's markets and in our cafe in San Francisco, this customer favorite dessert is now available to purchase online so you get to enjoy it in the comfort of your home anywhere in the country.

This pie is perishable and ships pre-baked and frozen with recommendations for serving. 

Size: 9" Pie

Serves: 8-10

Ingredients: organic sugar, water, organic cream, organic pumpkin puree, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, salt, Organic eggs

Pie Dough: Organic flour, Organic butter, leaflard, Water, Sugar, Salt


Manufactured in a facility that processes tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, milk, and eggs.

Chef Becky uses a combination of organic butter and 100% pasture raised leaf lard from Prather Ranch for her pie dough. This combination makes for a light and flaky crust with a buttery taste that is sure to delight.

Shipping Details

Shipments may be delayed until the following week based on availability. If you have any requirements for arrival dates, please let us know.

  • This product is perishable and ships frozen. Keep frozen until baking.
  • With standard shipping, this item ships Monday through Wednesday for delivery within two to three business days.
  • For more information on our Shipping Deadlines, visit:
  • Shipping is not available to PO and APO Box addresses.
  • We do not ship C.O.D. and we do not require a signature for a package to be left unless requested.
  • Free local pick-up is only available to residents of Brentwood (Northern California) and neighboring towns who would like to pick-up from the farm in person. For more information, click here.

Ordering multiples or corporate gifts? Give us a call at 888-779-4511 and we can help.

Shipping Details

From our family farm in California to your door via UPS Carbon Neutral Shipment. That means, UPS will offset the climate impact of the shipment. UPS's carbon neutral shipping supports projects that offset the emissions of the shipment's transport. UPS has supported projects that include reforestation, landfill gas destruction, wastewater treatment, and methane destruction. View more details about our shipping rates, order deadlines, delivery estimates, and fulfillment schedule for our perishable vs. non-perishable products.

We are doing everything we can to get your orders to you in a timely manner, but please be aware that due to heightened demand our fulfillment partner UPS has issued a service alert and is experiencing shipping delays to all U.S. destinations. Thanks for your patience and if you have any questions please contact us.

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
Caramel Pumpkin Pie

Absolutely delicious.
Charming to look at too.

Fantastic pumpkin pie!!

We just enjoyed this pie with friends & this has to be one of the best pumpkin pies we’ve ever had. The intense pumpkin flavor is enhanced by the right amount of spice. We’re ordering another for Thanksgiving! Again, completely happy with another creation from your bakery.

Search our shop