Shaker Meyer Lemon Pie

Here is Chef Becky’s take on the classic Shaker pie using our own California grown organic Meyer lemons. Made traditionally by the Shaker communities throughout New England, our farm kitchen follows the same methods to create these fragrant lemon-centric pies using the entire fruit, peels and all. The rich crust is perfectly balanced with the aromatic and tart lemon filling. Our handsome pie will the center of any Sunday gathering. The Shaker Lemon Pie is 9" and serves 8-10 people.


Crust: Organic flour, organic butter, leaf lard.
Filling: Organic Meyer lemons, organic sugar, organic flour, organic butter, salt.

Storage & Handling

Remove pie from packaging and place it in the refrigerator on a flat surface. Remove and let sit for 2 hours before serving.

The Frog Hollow Farm Guarantee

Our promise to you: if your order doesn't arrive fresh and if you or your recipients aren't delighted, we'll make it right.

Carbon Neutral Shipping

Our commitment to the planet means that we offset the climate impact of every order with carbon-neutral shipping which supports projects that offset the emissions of the shipment's transport.

Orders placed on Monday and Tuesday, will ship the following day.

Orders placed Wednesday through Sunday will ship the following week, except Wednesday orders placed with Next Day or Ground to Zone 1.

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews
Hopeful Memory

More sweet than I would have liked and more than a bit different from the original version made at Kentucky’s Pleasant Hill Shaker Village, which is why I ordered it. Still, I was excited that you chose to recreate it and so I couldn’t wait to try it. The pastry was delicious, it was the lemon filling that was not what I hoped for. Nonetheless, your baked goods products that I have tried have all been delicious. I’m a big fan!


I wasn’t a big fan of the pie and I love lemons. Just a little different. Took a little Time to actually be shipped but once it finally was I received it the next day. Well packaged and secured.

Shaker Meyer Lemon Pie

Really different & really good

Meyer Lemon Pie

Wow! It truly had the meyer lemon flavor with minimal sweetness. And an amazing crust as well..

Search our shop