Best Seller

Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil


We have a special relationship with this grower, producer, and miller of olive oil; they have been milling our olives in their state-of-the-art olive press since 2005. They have acted as our nursery and ag advisor and have been an invaluable partner for many years in our olive oil journey.

Every year's olive harvest is different. 2020 harvest of McEvoy Ranch olive oil is a highly complex blend of bold pepperiness and a brightly bitter finish with prominent flavors of chicory, radicchio, dandelion greens and artichoke and aromas of freshly cut grass, green tea, and winter greens. This year's harvest finds an olive oil with remarkably high polyphenol levels, a potent antioxidant that has been shown to provide a host of health benefits including lowering cholesterol, blood pressure, and inflammation.

Tasting Note: This oil is not for the faint of heart! It is a true Tuscan blend with a bold and pungent finish. We’ve recommended adding a dab of butter to balance out the bitter finish when cooking. It is best for bread dipping, salads, and low heat cooking.


  • 375ml bottle (McEvoy Ranch)
  • 500ml bottle (McEvoy Ranch)
  • Half Gallon jar (McEvoy Ranch)
  • One Gallon = 2 x Half Gallon jars (McEvoy Ranch)
  • 375ml Case =  12 x 375ml bottles (McEvoy Ranch)
  • 500ml Case = 12 x 500ml bottles (McEvoy Ranch)

Storage & Handling 

  • Store in a cool, dark area away from sunlight. Fridge not highly recommended. 
  • The antioxidants and polyphenols (the anti-inflammatory portion) break down when exposed to heat, sunlight, drastic weather changes.
  • If stored correctly, it is recommended to use within 6-8 months of purchase.

The Frog Hollow Farm Guarantee

Our promise to you: if your order doesn't arrive fresh and if you or your recipients aren't delighted, we'll make it right.

Carbon Neutral Shipping

Our commitment to the planet means that we offset the climate impact of every order with carbon-neutral shipping which supports projects that offset the emissions of the shipment's transport.

Orders placed on Monday and Tuesday, will ship the following day.

Orders placed Wednesday through Sunday will ship the following week, except Wednesday orders placed with Next Day or Ground to Zone 1.

Customer Reviews

Based on 81 reviews
Joan Lunderville

Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Susan Spencer
Olive oil

I love the mild flavor of your olive oil and use it with everything instead of butter

Brenda Goldberg
Excellent organic extra virgin olive oil!!

I have been purchasing imported organic extra virgin olive oil from Tuscany and decided to try Frog Hollow’s instead. I will now be switching! The Frog Hollow olive oil has a milder, more buttery taste. Also, it comes in a small bottle so that it stays fresh all month whereas the larger bottles from Italy always taste a bit “off” before you totally finish them. We were extremely satisfied!!

Phyllis K Fess Baker

This is my hand-down favorite and looked for a long time to find it---tasting many I would not use. I buy this each time it's available and I put it in my OO cabinet in front where I can always reach it. Even though I've bought other "OOs" {$$$$} this beats everyone of them. When it's out; I either beg---or wait. Thanks frog Hollow Farmers and Teams. Phyllis K Fess Baker

Theresa Carson

The olive oil is excellent !

Search our shop